Add These Chewy Pumpkin Spice Cookies To Your Fall Bucket Record, Stat

Pumpkin spice is the flavour that by no means stops giving. From lattés to candles to pumpkin bread, there’s nothing fairly just like the alchemy of those elements to immediately present all of the autumn thrills I crave (even when it’s nonetheless too sizzling for denims.) Fundamental? Maybe. But when being obsessive about pumpkin all the things is incorrect, then I don’t need to be proper.

Since I’ve already baked my justifiable share of pumpkin bread this 12 months (and actually, it’s laborious to enhance on perfection), I made a decision it was time to show my consideration to creating the most effective pumpkin cookie recipe. And I discovered it in these Chewy Pumpkin Spice Cookies with Cinnamon Glaze. Scroll on to see how this heat and chewy cookie with its candy and spicy taste comes collectively (sure, multi function bowl.)

What Makes This Pumpkin Cookie Recipe Irresistible

These cookies are a bit like mini pumpkin breads, one way or the other staying chewy and by no means dry for days on finish. They’re scrumptious straight out of the oven, and even higher drizzled with the candy cinnamon glaze. Should you’re feeling daring, sandwich them with a little bit of cream cheese frosting within the center for a straightforward pumpkin whoopie pie.

These will certainly be my official Halloween cookie this 12 months. Skip the cookie cutters and piping luggage, and take the straightforward route for trainer presents and Halloween events this fall—everybody will thanks.

Components for Chewy Pumpkin Spice Cookies

This pumpkin cookie recipe is made with only a handful of elements that I at all times maintain readily available, making them good for these weekends while you all of the sudden really feel an urge to bake. Right here’s what’s going into this one-bowl recipe:

Melted Unsalted butter

Utilizing melted butter in cookies makes them denser and chewier, slightly than cakey.

Brown Sugar

Once more, brown sugar is denser than white sugar, that means that your cookie will rise much less and keep chewier.

Egg Yolk

In response to Serious Eats, utilizing an additional egg yolk in your cookies is the key to getting that gentle and chewy texture.


My mother’s secret to nice baking? At all times add double the quantity of vanilla recipe requires. I’ve already doubled it for you right here.

Canned pumpkin Puree

I’m a giant fan of high-quality canned pumpkin, and use it by the autumn and winter months in all the things from bread to smoothies to in a single day oats. On this recipe, you’re going to blot out the additional moisture with a paper towel to take away a few of the pumpkin’s water content material.

All-purpose flour

I stored it basic right here, however be happy to substitute along with your favourite gluten-free flour.

Baking soda

Though we wish these cookies to be on the denser and chewier facet, we’ll nonetheless incorporate a chemical leavening agent to assist them rise simply sufficient.


A pinch of salt balances the candy and spicy flavors.

Pumpkin Pie Spice

Pop quiz: what spices go into pumpkin pie spice? Should you don’t have any of this basic combine readily available, be happy so as to add every of those particular person spices that go into it (right here’s a pumpkin pie spice recipe, to get your ratios proper):

  • cinnamon
  • nutmeg
  • cloves
  • ginger
  • allspice

The right way to make this chewy pumpkin cookie recipe

This cookie dough comes collectively in basic type. You’re going to cream the butter, sugar, egg yolk, vanilla, and pumpkin in a big bowl. Then, you’ll add the dry elements and blend simply till mixed.

Most cookie recipe are going to let you know to combine the dry elements in a separate bowl, nevertheless since I’m a lazy baker who hates washing dishes, I are likely to dump my flour combination in a heap proper in the identical giant mixing bowl as my moist elements, use a fork to ensure they’re evenly distributed, then stir all of it collectively. And it at all times works, so do your self a favor and make all of your cookies in a single bowl transferring ahead.

This recipe requires chilling the dough for an hour within the fridge earlier than baking, which is clutch for getting that dense, chewy texture we’re after. I exploit a cookie scoop to yield completely equal-sized cookies that appears Insta-worthy.


What makes these cookies gentle and chewy?

As talked about above, using melted butter (as a substitute of softened), brown sugar (as a substitute of granulated), and one egg yolk (as a substitute of a complete egg) are our secret elements to nailing the chewy cookie we’re after. Plus, the pumpkin naturally makes these extremely moist. I’ve left mine out on the counter in a ziploc for as much as 4 days, and was shocked that my cookie was nonetheless gentle and under no circumstances dry.

How do you retain cookie dough from spreading?

Let your melted butter cool. I do know, it’s laborious to be affected person, however you’re positively going to need to let your melted butter quiet down earlier than including it to the blending bowl in order that your cookies don’t unfold into one large greasy puddle within the oven.

Use parchment paper. I at all times advocate lining your cookie sheet with parchment paper, as a substitute of spraying it with nonstick cooking spray, which tends to create a greasy floor that encourages spreading.

Chill the dough. Since it is a “wetter” dough (sorry for the terminology) you’re going to relax the dough for at the very least an hour within the fridge (or for those who’re impatient like me, half-hour within the freezer.) This helps the cookies from spreading and yields thicker, chewier cookies.

How do I retailer pumpkin cookies?

These cookies (and the dough!) maintain superbly. Listed below are your choices:

The right way to retailer further cookie dough: Chill the cookie batter for as much as 5 days within the fridge, and also you’ll have fresh-baked cookies on the prepared every time cravings strike. You could need to take away the dough from the fridge about quarter-hour earlier than scooping into balls, simply to make it a bit simpler.

The right way to retailer leftover cookies: Retailer baked cookies in an hermetic container at room temperature for as much as 4 days. I used to be shocked at how lengthy these stayed moist and scrumptious. Good for packing as a lunchbox deal with!

The right way to freeze cookie dough. Roll the dough into balls, then place on a plate within the freezer till they harden. (This helps the dough balls from sticking collectively.) Switch to a ziploc freezer bag, and freeze for as much as a month. When able to bake, you possibly can pop them proper onto a baking sheet, and simply add a pair minutes to their baking time.

Different cozy cookies to strive

Bored with pumpkin? We received you. Listed below are another fall favorites:

Peanut Butter Banana Cookies (Gluten-Free)

Double Chocolate Skillet Cookie

The best peanut butter cookies on the Internet.

Now scroll on to get the recipe for these Chewy Pumpkin Cookies with Cinnamon Glaze! Should you make them, be sure you depart us a score and overview, and tag us on Instagram so we will see your cookies.



Leave a Reply