Navigating Most cancers and Boundaries, One Particular person at a Time

“It was so scary at first,” mentioned Elizabeth Schalau, of Mill Creek, Washington, who was recognized with most cancers simply earlier than COVID-19 hit in early 2020. “I used to be being bombarded with all this information, attempting to wrap my head round it. I didn’t even know what ‘metastatic’ was.”

Not solely was the 54-year-old overwhelmed to be taught she had stage 4 (or metastatic) most cancers that had unfold from her breast to her pelvic bones, she was additionally coping with unwanted side effects from chemo, ache from the most cancers itself and juggling her cashier job with dozens of therapy appointments. When her employer demanded she work night time shifts, she was lastly pressured to give up.  

“I used to be in shock about dropping my job and having to be in a health care provider’s care,” she mentioned. “I used to be having hassle strolling, panicked about cash, so I known as Anne who’d launched herself to me once I was first recognized. She helped with monetary help and directed me to completely different applications. Having any individual like Anne was a lifesaver.”

“Anne” is Anne Devine, the affected person navigator supervisor at Seattle Most cancers Care Alliance (now Fred Hutchinson Most cancers Heart). Devine heads a group whose job it’s to assist sufferers navigate the difficult most cancers care system. Based in 2007, the affected person navigation program has turn out to be an integral half not simply of Fred Hutch’s supportive care services, however the establishment’s strategy to well being fairness.

“We actually need to promote well being fairness. That’s an actual dedication all of us have,” mentioned Devine, who’s been with this system for 8 years. “All of us are right here as a result of we need to assist folks.”

Dr. Jay Mendoza, a pediatrician and director of the Fred Hutch/College of Washington/Seattle Youngsters’s Most cancers Consortium’s Office of Community Outreach & Engagement, which companions with the navigation group, mentioned the work they’re doing is all a part of the Most cancers Consortium’s mission to offer higher most cancers outcomes for everyone.

“Underserved populations typically have a really difficult time accessing most cancers care on the frequency and depth it’s wanted,” he mentioned. “We’re actually eager about serving to to shut the gaps in care which are sometimes created by our programs. The well being care system normally is fairly byzantine. It’s not straightforward to get by even for those who’re coming from inside. These navigators do a tremendous job of closing gaps, making folks really feel welcome and ensuring there’s a well-recognized face that sufferers and their households can flip to for assist.”

Relatability and essential assets

What providers do affected person navigators present?

“Good pragmatic assist,” Devine mentioned. “Folks say it’s the logistics that freak them out much more than the most cancers. They’re attempting to determine easy methods to do all of it and afford all of it. The commonest points are transportation and monetary help, together with insurance coverage protection, treatment co-pays, medical lodging, deciphering providers and emotional help.”

Cultural bridging is one other space the place the navigators make a giant distinction.

“We assist sufferers talk with suppliers once they don’t perceive one thing,” Devine mentioned. “We might be within the room with them. We’re not medically licensed interpreters however we’re there to encourage folks to self-advocate and ask questions.”

Generally meaning translating the medical-speak into comprehensible English after which into one other language — the navigation group typically makes use of interpreters, both in particular person or by way of cellphone or video. Different instances it’s about understanding essential cultural touchpoints.

Affected person navigator Ahreum Yang, who’s Korean American, works primarily with Asian American and Pacific Islander, or AAPI, populations.

“After I join with somebody from an Asian background, I can provide a stage of relatability,” she mentioned. “Having somebody that has the identical background and cultural understanding makes it lots simpler to create a secure house for households and people.”

Understanding a bit a couple of tradition additionally helps perceive behaviors that seemingly don’t make sense, like not asking for assist.

“I’ve seen in folks with a Korean background there’s not an inclination to ask for too many issues,” Yang mentioned. “So it’s essential to construct belief and ask questions on what they want.”

Navigators additionally step in once they see a affected person struggling. Jennifer Deas, who normally focuses on breast most cancers sufferers, mentioned she just lately discovered of a affected person who was having hassle arranging transportation to and from her remedies.

“There was an expectation that she would name Hope Link [which provides services to low-income people] and arrange her transportation,” mentioned Deas, who, just like the affected person, is African American. “However this lady had throat most cancers. In talking together with her, I might perceive why it was so troublesome. Should you can’t talk, you may’t name and prepare transportation. I instructed her, ‘I’ve acquired this. I can do it for you.’”

Navigating most cancers and obstacles to care

Dr. Harold Freeman, the Harlem surgeon who got here up with the concept of affected person navigation in 1990, envisioned it as a “community-based service supply intervention designed to advertise entry to well timed analysis and therapy of most cancers and different persistent ailments by eliminating obstacles to care.”

In different phrases, it gives assets and help providers to the individuals who most want them. However the idea has modified over time, mentioned Dr. Scott Ramsey, a well being care providers researcher and director of the Hutchinson Institute for Cancer Outcomes Research who’s studied the worth of affected person navigation in most cancers care.

“Freeman began this as a result of in these very underserved populations, folks would obtain a brand new analysis of most cancers, disappear for months or years, then present up once more when their most cancers was incurable,” Ramsey mentioned. “Freeman discovered they couldn’t navigate the system, so he began this system to assist them. It was a lifesaving problem for these of us. Then it morphed into this factor the place all people wanted a navigator.”

Quickly, he mentioned, each most cancers heart had one thing akin to a affected person navigator, though their roles may very well be fairly completely different from Freeman’s mannequin. The time period quickly started to use to anybody, from the one that helps you pick the most effective medical insurance plan on the trade, a part of the Affordable Care Act, to a industrial affected person navigator who gives their providers for a payment.

“There are nurse navigators, well being care navigators and social staff who do related issues,” Mendoza mentioned, talking of the assorted applications throughout the nation. “However right here at Fred Hutch, we’re attempting to carry it dwelling to its authentic intent — to assist those that are underserved and underrepresented in our well being care system.”

Serving to these sufferers is essential since they typically have worse well being outcomes because of obstacles to care, Mendoza mentioned.

“Some medical facilities have VIP applications, applications for individuals who fly in on their non-public jets,” he mentioned. “We’re turning that on its head and recognizing that the true VIPs are those that are underserved.”

In Washington state, meaning sufferers from racial and ethnic populations which are underrepresented in medication; folks from low socioeconomic-status households, LGBTQ+ of us and people who reside in rural areas.

Because of group grants and different funding, the Hutch’s program has grown over time from two employees members to seven, with every navigator now assigned to a selected inhabitants or section of sufferers. Just lately, the group has adopted a extra proactive mannequin, reaching out to sufferers to introduce themselves and their providers earlier than a necessity turns into crucial.

Navigation employees now contains Devine, who supervises the group and covers sufferers normally oncology, together with Andrea Suzuki, a Spanish speaker; Chloe Fisher who works within the girls’s heart, together with Deas; John Masembe, who serves Black, African American and African-descent populations; Lenora Starr, who serves Indigenous patients; and Yang, who helps AAPI populations.

A job that takes coronary heart

A lot of the work is about being there for folks throughout an especially troublesome time and listening to sufferers’ spoken and unstated wants. And the work just isn’t straightforward.

Devine mentioned the affected person navigation group sees quite a lot of struggling, and never all of it because of most cancers.

“The social circumstances that persons are going through can simply be dire,” she mentioned. “The social conditions are typically more durable than the most cancers.”

Shedding sufferers is difficult, as properly. Yang nonetheless thinks a couple of couple who traveled to Seattle from Hawaii for the husband’s care. Sadly, his most cancers was way more superior than they realized and the person died quickly after beginning therapy.

“They thought that they had much more time,” she mentioned. “I ended up serving to her get the funeral arrange, serving to her request the information. It’s laborious to navigate that course of. I used to be in a position to make it a bit smoother for her.”

That couple holds “a particular place in my coronary heart,” Yang mentioned. It was working with them that she got here to grasp the significance of what she does.

“That was the second I noticed this function isn’t nearly serving to fill out paperwork or discovering assets,” she mentioned. “It’s being a cultural navigator too and serving to these folks get by a very troublesome time with a bit extra help.”

That help extends to one another, as properly. Devine mentioned she is happy with how her group has all pulled collectively to assist sufferers and each other.

“I don’t suppose any of our group will ever be resistant to the compassion fatigue,” she mentioned. “I attempt to remind my group that as laborious because the job is, they’re form of a vibrant spot for folks oftentimes. There’s an environment of caring right here and I believe folks actually worth that.”

Sharing their affected person experiences with one different helps, too, Yang mentioned.

“It helps that the opposite navigators expertise the identical factor,” she mentioned. “All of us remind each other what we’re doing is significant. We don’t have the flexibility to remedy a most cancers or give somebody a house, however we will make a distinction.”

A sensitivity to bias

For Deas, sharing these assets with the group is crucial.

“Sufferers don’t know they’ve these assets accessible,” she mentioned, including that her personal uncle, who lived in Tacoma, just lately died of throat most cancers, which if caught early is usually survivable.

Sadly, his most cancers was misdiagnosed for years.

“With African American males, quite a lot of issues are misdiagnosed,” she mentioned. “It took one good ER resident to lastly work out he had throat most cancers and never a sore throat or bronchitis. By that point, it had unfold. He had surgical procedure, however they didn’t get all of it.”

After surgical procedure, she mentioned, her uncle developed a lump.

“After I addressed it together with his medical group, they lastly examined it and confirmed that the most cancers was again and it was aggressive,” she mentioned. “My uncle finally died. However had he had a few of our transportation assets, he might need determined to journey to Seattle for his therapy. He was a proud man and comfort performed a significant function in persevering with his care domestically. Affected person navigation would have made a giant distinction in my uncle’s care.”

Deas mentioned experiences like which have ready her for the work she does with most cancers sufferers at present.

“Due to the issues I’ve been uncovered to, I’ve extra sensitivity to the challenges persons are going by,” she mentioned.

However navigating the system for sufferers is barely a part of what must be performed to enhance well being outcomes, she added.

“Getting folks entry to care is an effective factor for the group,” she mentioned. “However we have to do lots higher with constructing belief, getting extra Black, Indigenous and other people of shade into our trials and getting our boots locally. Now we have to speculate.”

Respecting different beliefs

Exhibiting cultural humility and respect is how navigators construct belief, she mentioned, whether or not it’s recognizing cultural practices or respecting household energy buildings.

“Someone who doesn’t come from an Indigenous background might not perceive using ceremonial tobacco or might not perceive eager to attempt different strategies to regulate their ache,” Deas mentioned. “As a group, we have to acknowledge that there are alternative ways to get to the answer; you need to respect folks’s beliefs.”

And that may typically be troublesome, she mentioned, recalling one household with an grownup daughter with most cancers. As an alternative of talking on to the affected person, the household requested the physician share the prognosis and therapy suggestions with the pinnacle of the household.

“The grandfather made all of the medical selections for this household,” Deas mentioned. “And at first, the care particular person on the group was like, ‘I’m not speaking to him. She has to make her personal selections.’”

In such circumstances, affected person navigators must set typical beliefs apart and respect the household dynamic, Deas mentioned.

“We might not prefer it they usually might not get therapy in any respect,” she mentioned. “In that occasion, this feminine was scared and she or he counted on her help system to make the most effective resolution for her. No matter how we felt, it was not our resolution, it was theirs. Finally, the care particular person was in a position to speak to the elder and current all the things.”

Measuring success, transferring ahead

Mendoza mentioned the OCOE is presently analyzing knowledge from affected person surveys to measure the effectiveness of this system. Outcomes will almost definitely be launched subsequent 12 months.

“We’re taking a look at from once we first introduced within the affected person navigators for Indigenous and Black/African-descent populations [about 18 months ago],” he mentioned. “That’s once we reoriented issues from being a crisis-care mannequin to at least one that’s proactive and longitudinal in nature.”

His hope is that this system will show profitable sufficient that it may be expanded to Fred Hutch’s other locations across the Seattle space and elsewhere in Washington state.

“Providing this service to sufferers irrespective of the place they’re being cared for can be implausible,” he mentioned.

However that requires funding, after all.

“Proper now, a few of our navigators are funded by grants which is fantastic however nerve-wracking,” he mentioned. “What if the grant doesn’t come by? We’ve all seen that occur. Ensuring the navigators are funded by the Hutch’s operational price range can be a beautiful strategy to acknowledge how essential and important they’re to the care group.”

Even with out the survey knowledge to again it up, Mendoza believes the affected person navigation program has completely confirmed its worth.

“This is without doubt one of the most unheralded applications at our heart nevertheless it’s probably the most essential,” he mentioned. “They elevate the establishments. A number of the tales they inform us of their encounters with sufferers are merely breathtaking. And a few should do with small issues that make an enormous distinction to the affected person.”

For Schalau, the metastatic breast most cancers affected person that Devine helped with monetary assets, these little issues can imply all the things.

“To start with, I used to be in shock,” she mentioned. “I known as Anne a couple of instances to get recommendation and a pep speak and she or he was very useful each time. She hooked me up with the precise applications; she’d additionally let you know to ask for this, pay attention to that. These little hints have been lifesaving. And she or he didn’t pity me. She by no means got here off that manner. She even put my title in for a Christmas giveaway and I acquired some grocery reward playing cards. That was so candy; these touches have been simply fabulous.”

This story was revealed by Fred Hutch News Service on June 28, 2022. It’s republished with permission.



Leave a Reply