Racial, ethnic biases in pulse oximetry accuracy could have delayed COVID-19 therapy for some

June 17, 2022

2 min learn

Disclosures: Fawzy reviews no related monetary disclosures. Please see the research for all different authors’ related monetary disclosures.

Racial and ethnic biases in pulse oximetry accuracy could have resulted in delays and unrecognized eligibility for COVID-19 therapies amongst Black and Hispanic sufferers, in line with outcomes of a cohort research in JAMA Inner Drugs.

“The COVID-19 pandemic shone a highlight on pulse oximeters as a useful gizmo for making triage and therapy selections, which begged the query of whether or not the beforehand reported inaccuracy of pulse oximeters in racial and ethnic minorities could have impacted how these sufferers had been handled,” Ashraf Fawzy, MD, MPH, assistant professor of drugs within the division of pulmonary and significant care medication at Johns Hopkins College College of Drugs, informed Healio. “Our research supplies new proof that the inaccuracy of pulse oximeters in sufferers of shade could have led to a delay in these sufferers receiving vital and probably lifesaving remedies for COVID-19.”

Ashraf Fawzy, MD, MPH, quote
Information had been derived from Fawzy A, et al. JAMA Intern Med. 2022;doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2022.1906.

The retrospective cohort research included knowledge from 7,126 patients with COVID-19 (41.7% girls) from 5 referral facilities and neighborhood hospitals within the Johns Hopkins Well being System who had COVID-19 and self-identified as Black (39.3%), Hispanic (17.7%), Asian (5.2%) or white (37.8%). Fawzy and colleagues analyzed SpO2 measurements and SaO2 values from arterial blood gases within the sufferers’ digital medical data. Occult hypoxemia was outlined as an SaO2 lower than 88% with an SpO2 of 92% to 96%. In sufferers with concurrent SpO2 and SaO2 measurements, the proportion with occult hypoxemia had been in contrast by race and ethnicity.

The first consequence was the distinction between SpO2 and SaO2 measurements occurring inside 10 minutes of each other. The secondary consequence was the distinction in time to recognition of therapy eligibility with oxygen threshold-specific COVID-19 therapies between racial and ethnic underrepresented teams and white sufferers with COVID-19.

General, 1,216 sufferers had 32,282 concurrently measured SpO2 and SaO2 ranges.

Occult hypoxemia occurred in 30.2% of Asian sufferers, 28.5% of Black sufferers and 29.8% of non-Black Hispanic sufferers in contrast with 17.2% of white sufferers.

In accordance with the researchers, SpO2 overestimated SaO2 by 1.7% amongst Asian sufferers, 1.2% amongst Black sufferers and 1.1% amongst non-Black Hispanic sufferers in contrast with white sufferers. As well as, in contrast with white sufferers, among the many 1,903 sufferers with predicted SaO2 ranges of 94% or much less earlier than an SpO2 stage of 94% or much less or oxygen therapy initiation, the likelihood of therapy eligibility recognition was 29% decrease amongst Black sufferers (HR = 0.71; 95% CI, 0.63-0.8) and 23% decrease amongst non-Black Hispanic sufferers (HR = 0.77; 95% CI, 0.66-0.89).

Amongst 451 sufferers in whom therapy eligibility was not acknowledged, 54.8% had been Black. Among the many 1,452 sufferers in whom therapy eligibility was finally acknowledged, Black sufferers skilled a median delay of 1 hour (P = .01) longer than white sufferers.

“The inaccuracy of pulse oximeters in individuals of shade has been reported way back to 1990 and has been replicated by a number of current research. We additionally know that Black and Hispanic sufferers have had poorer outcomes after COVID-19, so it was not significantly stunning that inaccuracies in a software that we relied on closely could have led to delays in care,” Fawzy informed Healio. “Which may be one piece of the puzzle that explains why these sufferers had poorer outcomes via research investigating that affiliation are needed.”

The researchers reported no vital median distinction in therapy eligibility delay between people of different racial/ethnic underrepresented teams and white sufferers.

“Future analysis wants to research the underlying the explanation why we’re discovering this inaccuracy in pulse oximetry amongst racial and ethnic minority sufferers,” Fawzy stated. “Finally, the medical neighborhood might want to reengineer the heart beat oximeters so that they work extra equitably for all sufferers.”

For extra info:

Ashraf Fawzy, MD, MPH, may be reached at [email protected]


Leave a Reply